Based on your other posts, you are very liberal, which is ok, but also means you don't always give the market (free, black, or otherwise credit.) If there is a need/want, someone will make them somewhere. We've seen that most recently with gambling, which has been ahead of government regulation for some time. Daily fantasy, poker (legal for quite some time before then illegal...well, illegal in a way, they did it more through the banks) all filled a need that was borderline and now in poker's case, illegal. If you have more than a handful who want something, illegal or not, someone will come up with it. If illegal, generally the criminal enterprises will have better access than those who aren't, simply because they traditionally avoid banks and such and operate almost exclusively on untraceable cash basis. Now, I challenge those in favor of GC to do something that I've never seen done...run the actual stats on gun homocide (excluding self defense shootings) of legally owned versus illegally owned weapons. Even you have to admit, with guns illegal, its not as if those who already have them illegally are going to turn them in and if they commit a crime, its already a prosecutable gun crime anyway.