All-Time Picks
- 1. Notre Dame 525
- 2. USC 524
- 3. Ohio State 485
- 4. Oklahoma 414
- 5. Alabama 401
- 5. Michigan 401
- 7. Penn State 381
- 8. LSU 375
- 9. Florida 373
- 10. Georgia 371
- 11. Nebraska 368
- 12. Tennessee 360
- 13. Miami (FL) 358
- 14. Texas 357
- 15. UCLA 337
- 16. Michigan State 322
- 17. Washington 315
- 18. Texas A&M 302
- 19. Pittsburgh 297
- 19. Wisconsin 297
- 21. Auburn 295
- 22. Purdue 292
- 23. Minnesota 280
- 24. Arkansas 279
- 25. Stanford 278
- 26. Florida State 277
- 27. Colorado 276
- 28. Clemson 274
- 29. Iowa 272
- 30. Ole Miss 258
- 31. Arizona State 255
- 31. Illinois 255
- 33. North Carolina 251
- 34. Baylor 249
- 35. California 244
- 36. Oregon 236
- 37. Maryland 228
- 38. Missouri 226
- 39. Georgia Tech 219
- 40. South Carolina 216
- 41. Boston College 214
- 42. Kentucky 212
- 42. TCU 212
- 44. Mississippi State 209
- 45. Syracuse 202
- 46. West Virginia 198
- 47. Washington State 197
- 48. Northwestern 188
- 49. Houston 187
- 50. Arizona 184
- 1. Ohio State 90
- 2. USC 85
- 3. Alabama 79
- 4. Notre Dame 70
- 5. Miami (FL) 67
- 6. Florida 58
- 7. Michigan 51
- 8. Oklahoma 50
- 9. LSU 49
- 10. Georgia 47
- 10. Tennessee 47
- 12. Florida State 46
- 12. Texas 46
- 14. Penn State 40
- 15. Clemson 39
- 16. Michigan State 36
- 16. Texas A&M 36
- 16. UCLA 36
- 19. Nebraska 34
- 20. Auburn 32
- 21. Wisconsin 30
- 22. Washington 28
- 23. California 27
- 23. Pittsburgh 27
- 25. Arizona State 26
- 25. Iowa 26
- 27. North Carolina 25
- 27. Stanford 25
- 29.C olorado 24
- 30. Arkansas 23
- 30. Illinois 23
- 32. Boston College 22
- 32. Ole Miss 22
- 32. Oregon 22
- 32. Purdue 22
- 36. Baylor 21
- 36. Oklahoma State 21
- 36. Syracuse 21
- 39. Missouri 20
- 40. North Carolina State 19
- 41. Maryland 18
- 41. Minnesota 18
- 41. TCU 18
- 44. Kentucky 16
- 44. Louisville 16
- 44. Mississippi State 16
- 44. Virginia 16
- 48. Houston 15
- 48. South Carolina 15
- 50. Virginia Tech 14
- 50. Washington State 14
- Georgia (5) — Travon Waker (2022), Matthew Stafford (2009), Harry Babcock (1953), Charley Trippi (1945), Frank Sinkwich (1943)
- Notre Dame (5) — Walt Patulski (1972), Paul Hornung (1957), Leon Hart (1950), Frank Dancewicz (1946), Angelo Bertelli (1944)
- Oklahoma (5) — Kyler Murray (2019), Baker Mayfield (2018), Sam Bradford (2010), Billy Sims (1980), Lee Roy Selmon (1976)
- Southern California (5) — Carson Palmer (2003), Keyshawn Johnson (1996), Ricky Bell (1977), O.J. Simpson (1969), Ron Yary (1968)
- Auburn (4) — Cam Newton (2011), Aundray Bruce (1988), Bo Jackson (1986), Tucker Frederickson (1965)
- Stanford (4) —Andrew Luck (2012), John Elway (1983), Jim Plunkett (1971), Bobby Garrett (1954)
- LSU (3) — Joe Burrow (2020), JaMarcus Russell (2007), Billy Cannon (1960)
- Ohio State (3) — Orlando Pace (1997), Dan Wilkinson (1994), Tom Cousineau (1979)
- Texas (3) — Kenneth Sims (1982), Earl Campbell (1978), Tommy Nobis (1966)
- Alabama (2) — Bryce Young (2023), Harry Gilmer (1948)
- California (2) —Jared Goff (2016), Steve Bartkowski (1975)
- Miami (Fla.) (2) — Russell Maryland (1991), Vinny Testaverde (1987)
- Michigan (2) —Jake Long (2008), Tom Harmon (1941)
- Nebraska (2) —Irving Fryar (1984), Sam Francis (1937)
- Penn State (2) — Courtney Brown (2000), Ki-Jana Carter (1995)
- South Carolina (2) — Jadeveon Clowney (2014), George Rogers (1981)
- Tennessee (2) —Peyton Manning (1998), George Cafego (1940)
- Virginia Tech (2) — Michael Vick (2001), Bruce Smith (1985)
- Central Michigan (1) — Eric Fisher (2013)
- Chicago (1) — Jay Berwanger (1936)
- Clemson (1) — Trevor Lawrence (2021)
- Colorado A&M (1) — Gary Glick (1956)
- Florida State (1)— Jameis Winston (2015)
- Fresno State (1) —David Carr (2002)
- Illinois (1) — Jeff George (1990)
- Iowa (1) — Randy Duncan (1959)
- Indiana (1) —Corbett Davis (1938)
- Kentucky (1) —Tim Couch (1999)
- Louisiana Tech (1) — Terry Bradshaw (1970)
- Michigan State (1) — Bubba Smith (1967)
- Mississippi (1) — Eli Manning (2004)
- North Carolina State (1) — Mario Williams (2006)
- Oklahoma State (1) — Bob Fenimore (1947)
- Oregon (1) — George Shaw (1955)
- Oregon State (1) —Terry Baker (1963)
- Pennsylvania (1) —Chuck Bednarik (1949)
- Rice (1) — King Hill (1958)
- Southern Methodist (1)— Kyle Rote (1951)
- Syracuse (1) — Ernie Davis (1962)
- Tampa (1) — John Matuszak (1973)
- TCU (1) — Ki Aldrich (1939)
- Tennessee State (1) — Ed 'Too Tall' Jones (1974)
- Texas A&M (1) —Myles Garrett (2017)
- Texas Tech (1) — Dave Parks (1964)
- Tulane (1) — Tommy Mason (1961)
- UCLA (1) — Troy Aikman (1989)
- Utah (1) — Alex Smith (2005)
- Vanderbilt (1) — Bill Wade (1952)
- Virginia (1) — Bill Dudley (1942)
- Washington (1) — Steve Emtman (1992)
- Washington State (1) — Drew Bledsoe (1993)